Harold Chang, CFA, has been the lead portfolio manager for the Woodlock Management Group (WMG) for the
last five years. WMG runs several equity and fixed income portfolios, all of which are authorized to use
derivatives as long as such positions are consistent with the portfolio's strategy. The WMG Equity Opportunities
Fund takes advantage of long and short profit opportunities in equity securities. The fund's positions are often a
relatively large percentage of the issuer's outstanding shares and fund trades frequently move securities prices.
Chang runs the Equity Opportunities Fund and is concerned that his performance for the last three quarters has
put his position as lead manager in jeopardy. Over the last three quarters, Chang has been underperforming his
benchmark by an increasing margin and is determined to reduce the degree of underperformance before the
end of the next quarter. Accordingly, Chang makes the following transactions for the fund:
Transaction 1: Chang discovers that the implied volatility of call options on GreenCo is too high. As a result,
Chang shorts a large position in the stock options while simultaneously taking a long position in GreenCo stock,
using the funds from the short position to partially pay for the long stock. The GreenCo purchase caused the
share price to move up slightly. After several months, the GreenCo stock position has accumulated a large
unrealized gain. Chang sells a portion of the GreenCo position to rebalance the portfolio.
Richard Stirr, CFA, who is also a portfolio manager for WMG, runs the firm's Fixed Income Fund. Stirr is known
for his ability to generate excess returns above his benchmark, even in declining markets. Stirr is convinced
that even though he has only been with WMG for two and a half years, he will be named lead portfolio manager
if he can keep his performance figures strong through the next quarter. To achieve this positive performance,
Stirr enters into the following transactions for the fund:
Transaction 2: Stirr decides to take a short forward position on the senior bonds of ONB Corporation, which
Stirr currently owns in his Fixed Income Fund. Stirr made his decision after overhearing two of his firm's
investment bankers discussing an unannounced bond offering for ONB that will subordinate all of its
outstanding debt. As expected, the price of the ONB bonds falls when the upcoming offering is announced. Stirr
delivers the bonds to settle the forward contract, preventing large losses for his investors.
Transaction 3: Sitrr has noticed that in a foreign bond market, participants are slow to react to new information
relevant to the value of their country's sovereign debt securities. Stirr, along with other investors, knows that an
announcement from his firm regarding the sovereign bonds will be made the following day. Stirr doesn't know
for sure, but expects the news to be positive, and prepares to enter a purchase order. When the positive news
is released, Stirr is the first to act, making a large purchase before other investors and selling the position after
other market participants react and move the sovereign bond price higher.
Because of their experience with derivatives instruments, Chang and Stirr are asked to provide investment
advice for Cherry Creek, LLC, a commodities trading advisor. Cherry Creek uses managed futures strategies
that incorporate long and short positions in commodity futures to generate returns uncorrelated with securities
markets. The firm has asked Chang and Stirr to help extend their reach to include equity and fixed income
derivatives strategies. Chang has been investing with Cherry Creek since its inception and has accepted increased shares in his Cherry Creek account as compensation for his advice. Chang has not disclosed his
arrangement with Cherry Creek since he meets with the firm only during his personal time. Stirr declines any
formal compensation but instead requests that Cherry Creek refer their clients requesting traditional investment
services to WMG. Cherry Creek agrees to the arrangement.
Three months have passed since the transactions made by Chang and Stirr occurred. Both managers met their
performance goals and are preparing to present their results to clients via an electronic newsletter published
every quarter. The managers want to ensure their newsletters are in compliance with CFA Institute Standards
of Professional Conduct. Chang states, "in order to comply with the Standards, we are required to disclose the
process used to analyze and select portfolio holdings, the method used to construct our portfolios, and any
changes that have been made to the overall investment process. In addition, we must include in the newsletter
all factors used to make each portfolio decision over the last quarter and an assessment of the portfolio's risks."
Stirr responds by claiming, "we must also clearly indicate that projections included in our report are not factual
evidence but rather conjecture based on our own statistical analysis. However, I believe we can reduce the
amount of information included in the report from what you have suggested and instead issue more of a
summary report as long as we maintain a full report in our internal records."
Determine whether Chang's comments regarding the disclosure of investment processes used to manage
WMG's portfolios and the disclosure of factors used to make portfolio decisions over the last quarter are
correct.
Dakota Watson and Anthony Smith are bond portfolio managers for Northern Capital Investment Advisors,
which is based in the U.S. Northern Capital has $2,000 million under management, with S950 million of that in
the bond market. Northern Capital's clients are primarily institutional investors such as insurance companies,
foundations, and endowments. Because most clients insist on a margin over the relevant bond benchmark,
Watson and Smith actively manage their bond portfolios, while at the same time trying to minimize tracking
error.
One of the funds that Northern Capital offers invests in emerging market bonds. An excerpt from its prospectus
reveals the following fund objectives and strategies:
“The fund generates a return by constructing a portfolio using all major fixed-income sectors within the Asian
region (except Japan) with a bias towards non-government bonds. The fund makes opportunistic investments
in both investment grade and high yield bonds. Northern Capital analysts seek those bond issues that are
expected to outperform U.S. bonds with similar credit risk, interest rate risk, and liquidity risk-Value is added by
finding those bonds that have been overlooked by other developed world bond funds. The fund favors nondollar, local currency denominated securities to avoid the default risk associated with a lack of hard currency on
the part of issuer."
Although Northern Capital does examine the availability of excess returns in foreign markets by investing
outside the index in these markets, most of its strategies focus on U.S. bonds and spread analysis of them.
Discussing the analysis of spreads in the U.S. bond market, Watson comments on the usefulness of the option
adjusted spread and the swap spread and makes the following statements:
Statement 1: Due to changes in the structure of the primary bond market in the U.S., the option adjusted
spread is increasingly valuable for analyzing the attractiveness of bond investments.
Statement 2: The advantage of the swap spread framework is that investors can compare the relative
attractiveness of fixed-rate and floating-rate bond markets.
Watson's view of the U.S. economy is decidedly bearish. She is concerned that the recent withdrawal of liquidity
from the U.S. financial system will result in a U.S. recession, possibly even a depression. She forecasts that
interest rates in the U.S. will continue to fall as the demand for loanable funds declines with the lack of business
investment. Meanwhile, she believes that the Federal Reserve will continue to keep short-term rates low in
order to stimulate the economy. Although she sees the level of yields declining, she believes that the spread on
risky securities will increase due to the decline in business prospects. She therefore has reallocated her bond
portfolio away from high-yield bonds and towards investment grade bonds.
Smith is less decided about the economy. However, his trading strategy has been quite successful in the past.
As an example of his strategy, he recently sold a 20-year AA-rated $50,000 Mahan Corporation bond with a
7.75% coupon that he had purchased at par. With the proceeds, he then bought a newly issued A-rated Quincy
Corporation bond that offered an 8.25% coupon. By swapping the first bond for the second bond, he enhanced
his annual income, which he considers quite favorable given the declining yields in the market.
Watson has become quite interested in the mortgage market. With the anticipated decline in interest rates, she
expects that the yields on mortgages will decline. As a result, she has reallocated the portion of Northern
Capital's bond portfolio dedicated to mortgages. She has shifted the holdings from 8.50% coupon mortgages to
7.75% coupon mortgages, reasoning that if interest rates do drop, the lower coupon mortgages will rise in price
more than the higher coupon mortgages. She identifies this trade as a structure trade.
Smith is examining the liquidity of three bonds. Their characteristics are listed in the table below:
Which of the following best describes the relative value analysis used in the Northern Capita! Emerging market